Eichler Homes: Eiffel Tower? Or Throwaways?

Two houses
A beautiful Eichler home on Louis Road in Palo Alto is getting a new neighbor -- a two-story home replacing another Eichler. Photo by Dave Weinstein

To true Eichler fans, the invective that some people throw at the poor homes can sound astounding. Nowhere is this clearer than in recent discussions about how to save the Eichlers of Palo Alto.

A group of Eichler owners, after watching one, then another, of these mid-century modern tract homes falling to make way for much larger, and infinitely blander, replacement homes, has asked the city of Palo Alto to create ‘single-story overlays’ to protect Eichlers throughout town.

The zoning, which is already in place in several Eichler neighborhoods throughout the Bay Area, including Greenmeadow in Palo Alto, would ban second-story additions and two-story replacement houses.

The charge is being led by a newly formed group, the Palo Alto Eichler Association. Its members include neighbors of a house that was demolished on Louis Road, and another on Richardson Court, and people from other Eichler neighborhoods as well. Another Eichler, on Corina Way, is also slated to be replaced by a new, larger home.

Louis Road
The new home on Louis Road will loom over its neighbor. The builder made concessions to preserve a degree of privacy. Photo by Dave Weinstein

In addition, in the neighboring city of Atherton, an amazing very early custom Eichler home recently bit the dust to make way for a larger replacement, despite attempts by fans to preserve it.

“We are a bunch of Eichler enthusiasts in Palo Alto banding together to protect and celebrate this unique form of living,” the group states on its website. “This lifestyle requires privacy from the road, and a uniform single-story tract setting to preserve privacy in the indoor-outdoor settings of our houses.”

Success in their endeavor is far from certain, as neighbors must win the backing of 60 to 70 percent of their neighbors to get such zoning.

The depth of the challenge becomes clear when reading through the many comments posted – anonymously, as too often is the norm these days – on the website of Palo Alto Online, which reported on the proposed overlay zone in May. Some of these comments are from neighbors of Eichler homes, and others are from people who actually live in the homes.

On Richardson Road in Palo Alto, a similar tale -- a two-story home arises alongside its Eichler neighbors. Photo by Dave Weinstein

“Eichers are not the Eiffel Tower or the Empire State building,” observed someone writing as ‘CrescentParkAnon.’ “Most of them are very worse off for wear. The foundations settle, crack, and open up to the ground, the in-floor radiant heating breaks and is expensive to fix and maintain. The construction had no insulation at all, and particularly the roofs are problematic.”

Fair enough, and nothing new, about the radiant heat and insulation. But why should a house be the Eiffel Tower? And how many tract houses, anywhere, are as architecturally distinctive in a modern manner as Eichlers? Few.

But to many people, including our anonymous writer from Crescent Park, distinction in a home is not a primary value. More important is the ability of a property owner to do what he or she wills with his property – a common comment.

“No, this is not because people think Eichlers are historic,” CrescentParkAnon goes on, “this is because people don't want other people coming in and building nicer houses around them, particularly since they will be taller. I can understand this, and sympathize with it as well, but I don't think it outweighs or justifies holding back progress or allowing people to improve their properties.”

808 Richardson Road is no longer an Eichler home. Photo by Dave Weinstein

But what do we mean by improve? If we mean “get a bigger house,” that’s right. But look at the homes that are replacing our sleek, glass-walled Eichlers. They are huge hunks of stylish nothing.

Then we have comments from folks who just simply know much more about Eichlers than anyone else. How did they get this knowledge? Why, directly from Joe himself. Oh, maybe not quite directly.

Consider the following comment from ‘Take it from Joe, a resident of Another Palo Alto neighborhood.’

“An elderly friend who once worked for Joe Eichler told me that: Eichler homes were designed for returning GI's who had minimum down payments, limited income, and VA financing. They were not meant to be permanent structures, but TEMPORARY homes for lower middle-class families -- to hold them over until they could afford to move or tear down and build a larger and more permanent structure. They were built on the cheap with materials that were cheap at that time.”

Ah! We get it. Eichlers, like World War II Quonset huts, were temporary structures, like earthquake shacks after the 1906 quake in San Francisco, or those formaldehyde-laced huts supplied to victims of Hurricane Katrina.

A very historic Eichler home stood until recently in a quiet Atherton neighborhood, a sprawling, large model that showed how even early Eichlers could be for upscale clients. Photo by Suzanne Dunn


And then we have people who just simply do not like the Eichler look, including ‘Over It,’ who admits to being a former Eichler owner:

“Sorry, but Eichlers are hideous. And from a planning perspective, they are the antithesis of progressive, community-fostering design. If you don't believe me, drive through an Eichler neighborhood and take a look at how many front doors and windows face the street. The average Eichler hides behind a front wall and a carport or garage door, with barely a bathroom window facing the street. That kind of design would be laughed to the curb under modern residential design guidelines. I don't care how mid-century modern the Eichlers are -- ugly is ugly.”

Alan – a real name, apparently – posting from Charleston Meadows summarizes what a lot of Eichler owners believe:

“Eichlers are all about letting in light. So when someone tears down and builds a two-story McMansion in an Eichler community, they are destroying that community. It doesn't work the other way, however. Eichlers need to be together to work, so it is only natural that these Eichler communities would want a single-story overlay protecting the intent.

“If someone wants to build a McMansion, go do it somewhere else.”

Oaks, a bit of fencing, and an empty lot are all that are left of the Atherton Eichler. Photo by Dave Weinstein

Reader Comments Box