Forum HomeCA-Modern ForumsGrab Bag Central › Pros and cons of removing asbestos tiles

Pros and cons of removing asbestos tiles

4 replies [Last post]
Joined: Feb 11 2005

We are wondering about long term air quality issues in weighing pros and cons of rinstalling new flooring over old asbestos containing tiles versus removing them first. Thank you for any information you may have about this.

Joined: Jan 4 2004

Most 9"X9" floor tiles have a fairly low (3%-15%) asbestos content.
If you are not going to be living in the home during the process, I'd suggest doing it.
The floor tiles are very easy to remove, and by lightly wetting them down,
you can eliminate the dust.
Of course, a respirator must be worn. Good luck.


Joined: Apr 2 2003


Hope I'm not stating the obvious, but there is a Search function on the Chatterbox Lounge that is very useful for looking up past postings on a subject. Look in the box at the top of the page (the one that holds the Eichler Network logo and various advertisements). You'll see links to the Log in and Search.

If you click on Search and then type the word asbestos in to the first search space, you should get a dozen or so topics that contained that word. Since the topic of asbestos has come up so many times in the past and some are tired of repeating themselves in a new post, using the Search function will probably yield useful info you might otherwise miss.

Good luck.

eichfan at rawbw dot com

Joined: Dec 14 2003

Of course, if the tiles are not removed, there is absolutely no risk to your air quality. The only risk that occurs (and it isn't much risk at that) is if the tile are being broken up in removal. If you would prefer to tile over them, that would be completely safe. The asbestos is not going to jump out of the tile and fly up into the air on it's own. It's a particle, not a gas.

Joined: Mar 20 2003

Those tiles have a wonderful way of absorbing odor--specifically animal urine, then affecting your "air quality." I would suggest that if you have animals that are not the most perfect pets and you are going to carpet, I would suggest removing the tiles. In our personal experience the previous owner had a very naughty puppy....when I was removing the tiles I wore a respirator for more than just the asbestos factor!

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.